Guest blog by Fit Minded’s CMO and neuroscientist, Laura Beavin-Yates, Ph.D.
Why do well-built digital health products still lose users?
Healthtech products often struggle with user engagement and retention because the experience doesn’t align with how the brain processes information, makes decisions, and forms habits. Applying what we know from neuroscience to product design can help teams understand what’s getting in the way and create experiences that make meaningful behavior change easier to achieve and sustain.
Sometimes the problem starts before users even experience the product’s value. Onboarding may require them to answer dozens of questions, connect devices, or set goals before they can get started. Other times, the experience may require them to track symptoms every day, navigate complicated instructions when they’re already stressed, or change routines in ways that simply aren’t realistic. Even a well-designed product can struggle if it doesn’t fit naturally into people’s lives and make it easier for them to achieve their goals.
And the research shows just how common this problem is. A review of 292 studies on mobile health tools found that among the studies that tracked engagement over time, 77% reported a decline in use. The review also found that people who engaged more with these tools were often more likely to stick with their recommended health behaviors, showing why keeping users engaged is so important.
When engagement drops, teams often respond by adding more features, notifications, or incentives. But before adding something else, we should be asking why people aren’t engaging in the first place.
Understanding how the brain works can help us answer that question and design experiences that better support the behaviors we’re trying to encourage.
Here are six ways neuroscience can help healthtech teams identify what’s getting in the way and improve the experiences they’re delivering.
How can the COM-B model improve healthtech product design?
Neuroscience helps us understand how the brain works, while behavioral science draws on that knowledge, along with psychology and other fields, to help explain why people do what they do.
One useful framework for applying this understanding to product design is COM-B, which looks at three things that influence whether someone takes action: capability, opportunity, and motivation.
A systematic review of 41 studies on health and wellbeing apps identified 26 factors that influence whether people start and continue using these products. All of them fit within these three core areas.
For healthtech teams, that means considering the following questions:
- Capability: Do users have the knowledge, skills, and mental energy to do what’s being asked? For example, a nutrition app might ask users to track their macronutrients without explaining what carbohydrates, proteins, and fats are or how to calculate them.
- Opportunity: Does the behavior realistically fit into their lives? A sleep program requiring a 30-minute evening routine may not work for someone on rotating night shifts.
- Motivation: Do users see enough value in the behavior to get started and keep going? For example, someone using a physical therapy app may understand that daily exercises will help them recover, but struggle to stay motivated when they don’t see any immediate improvement in their pain or mobility.
The important thing is understanding what’s actually getting in the way before trying to fix it. If someone stops using a product because they don’t have the time or resources to follow the program, adding more reminders or rewards isn’t likely to help. Understanding the barrier gives teams a much better starting point for improving the experience.
What is cognitive load in UX, and why does it matter during onboarding?
Our brains can only process so much information at once. Cognitive load refers to the mental effort required to take in information, make decisions, and complete tasks. When a product asks users to do too much at once, they may become overwhelmed and leave before experiencing its value.
Noom presents an interesting real-world example. A 2026 analysis by RevenueCat documented one of Noom’s web-to-app onboarding experiences, which included up to 113 screens and took approximately 10 to 15 minutes to complete. Noom uses several thoughtful design techniques throughout, including progress indicators, personalization, and explanations that help users understand the value of the program and why they’re being asked certain questions.
There’s real value in using onboarding to educate people about what a product can do for them and build motivation to get started. However, there’s also a balance to strike between communicating that value and overwhelming users before they’ve had a chance to experience it. Someone who’s highly motivated to start a weight management program might appreciate the detailed onboarding, while someone who’s already overwhelmed or short on time may have a very different experience.
The goal shouldn’t necessarily be to make onboarding as short as possible, but to make every step worthwhile. And rather than assuming you’ve found the right balance, it’s important to test how different users respond and where they may be dropping off.
A few questions healthtech teams should consider:
- How many decisions must users make before experiencing value?
- Are we helping users understand why the product matters to them, or simply explaining how it works?
- What information is essential now, and what can wait?
- Could users learn about a feature by trying it rather than reading instructions?
These questions also matter beyond onboarding. Someone trying to understand a concerning lab result or new diagnosis may already have a lot on their mind. Adding complicated instructions or unnecessary decisions can make an already difficult experience even harder.
How does expectation mismatch affect health app retention?
Our brains are constantly making predictions about what to expect based on past experiences and the information available to us. When someone signs up for a health app, what they’ve seen in advertising, read on the website, or heard from their clinician all shape what they expect the product to deliver.
A study of 343 health app users found that perceived usefulness, ease of use, and whether the app met users’ expectations were associated with their intention to keep using it.
Consider a sleep app that promises better sleep in seven days, even though its program is designed to produce improvements over several weeks. Users who don’t see results right away may assume the product isn’t working, even if they’re following the program as intended.
This is why marketing and product teams need to be aligned on the claims they’re making and the experience they’re delivering. Claims should be supported by evidence and give users a realistic understanding of what the product can deliver. When the experience delivers on those expectations, it can help build trust and encourage continued engagement.
Where is friction making the desired behavior harder?
Our attention is limited, and every element on a screen competes for it. Imagine opening a health app and seeing a daily check-in, content library, community feed, coaching prompt, and upgrade offer all competing for attention. Even if each feature has value, the experience may make it harder for users to figure out what to do next.
But not all friction is bad. Sometimes slowing users down can actually support better decisions. The important thing is understanding whether that friction helps or gets in the way of the behavior you’re trying to encourage.
- Unnecessary friction creates barriers without adding value, like requiring users to repeatedly enter information or navigate several screens to complete a simple task.
- Purposeful friction encourages more thoughtful action, like asking users to confirm a medication reminder change or reflect on their experience before completing a journal entry.
One way to evaluate this is to walk through the steps someone takes to complete a key action in your product. Where are you making things harder than they need to be, and where might a little extra thought actually improve the experience?
How do feedback and progress keep users engaged when health outcomes take months?
Our brains learn from feedback, using information about the results of our actions to guide future behavior. But in digital health, the outcomes people care about, like lower A1C, reduced anxiety, or improved cardiovascular fitness, often take weeks or months to become apparent. That’s a long time to keep putting in effort without knowing whether it’s making a difference.
When people don’t see evidence that their actions are helping them make progress, it can become harder to maintain motivation. A large review of digital health research, covering more than 865,000 participants, found evidence supporting approaches such as feedback, goal setting, coaching, and personalization to help people stick with healthy behaviors.
Consider a sleep app that rewards someone for logging in seven days in a row. The streak may encourage consistency, but it doesn’t tell them whether they’re actually sleeping better. Compare that with a progress summary showing that their average time to fall asleep has decreased since starting the program. Now they’re seeing progress tied to something they actually care about, which can help reinforce their motivation to continue.
Both approaches can have value, but the goal should be to help users recognize how their efforts are contributing to meaningful progress, rather than simply rewarding them for using the app.
How does memory shape whether users act on what they learn?
Just because someone understands something while using an app doesn’t mean they’ll remember it when they actually need it. And many healthtech products depend on users applying what they’ve learned outside the app, whether that’s making healthier food choices, managing stress, or following a treatment plan.
Research on learning and memory shows that spacing information out over time and asking people to recall what they’ve learned can help strengthen memory, compared with presenting everything at once.
For example, imagine a diabetes management app that teaches users how different foods affect blood sugar. Rather than presenting all that information during onboarding, the app could introduce one concept at a time, reinforce it through short activities, and help users apply what they’ve learned when planning meals.
The goal isn’t simply to give users information, but to design learning experiences that help them remember and apply it in their daily lives. Otherwise, even valuable educational content may have little impact on the behaviors the product is trying to change.
How can product teams test neuroscience-informed design?
Understanding how the brain works gives us a valuable foundation for designing better experiences, but that doesn’t mean we automatically know how users will respond. We still need to test our assumptions and measure whether the changes we’re making are having the intended impact.
For example:
- If we shorten onboarding and introduce goal setting later, will more users complete their first key action?
- If we replace streaks with feedback showing meaningful progress, will more users continue using the product?
- If we set more realistic expectations upfront, will fewer users abandon the program?
We also need to be careful about what we’re measuring. More time spent in an app doesn’t necessarily mean someone is having a better experience, and higher engagement doesn’t automatically translate into meaningful behavior change or improved health outcomes.
Surveys and interviews can help us understand what users think about an experience, but what people remember and report afterward doesn’t always reflect what happened in the moment. Combining that feedback with data on what users actually do, and where possible, measures collected during the experience, can help us better understand what’s working and what needs to change.
Design for the Brain, Measure What Matters
Understanding how the brain works can help us design healthtech products that fit more naturally into people’s lives, make meaningful behaviors easier, and support better health outcomes. But even when we’re applying well-established neuroscience principles, we can’t assume the experience is having the impact we intended. We need to measure it.
That’s where Fit Minded can help. We work with healthtech, wellness, femtech, and food-as-medicine companies to better understand user behavior, apply science to product decisions, and build evidence that supports meaningful outcomes and growth.
Book a meeting to explore how Fit Minded can help you identify barriers to engagement, improve your product experience, and measure whether those changes are leading to better outcomes.
Frequently Asked Questions About Neuroscience in Healthtech Product Design
How can neuroscience improve healthtech product design?
Neuroscience helps teams understand how people process information, make decisions, learn, and form habits. Applying these insights can help reduce barriers to engagement and design products that better support behavior change.
What is the COM-B model?
COM-B is a behavioral science framework that looks at three factors influencing behavior: capability, opportunity, and motivation. It helps product teams understand why users may not be taking a desired action.
How can healthtech companies improve user engagement and retention?
Start by understanding what’s preventing users from getting value from the product. That may include complicated onboarding, unclear benefits, unrealistic expectations, or experiences that don’t fit naturally into their lives. Test changes and measure whether they improve meaningful behaviors, not just app usage.
Turn neuroscience into smarter product design, stronger engagement, and better health outcomes.